Concerned about Strain Aging?
Not When Vanadium is Present!

For some steelmakers, adding nitrogen would seem to be the fastest way to send a heat to the scrap yard. So-called "free" nitrogen causes strain aging in carbon steels, increasing yield strength and brittleness after cold working. Strain aging is particularly detrimental in sheet products where it reduces formability.

However, when a nitride former such as vanadium is present, nitrogen becomes an extremely useful element. In high-strength, low-alloy steels, nitrogen combines with vanadium to become a very cost-effective strengthener.

Of the three nitride-forming elements - vanadium, aluminum, and titanium - vanadium is the only element that effectively strengthens steel by combining with nitrogen.

COMMERCIAL VERIFICATION

A technical paper presented at ISSTech 2003 in Indianapolis in April 2003 showed that vanadium sharply reduced strain aging in commercial HSLA steels. As shown in the graph below, plain-carbon steels containing as little as 0.006% nitrogen showed significant strain aging after simulated coil cooling. On the other hand, strain aging was virtually eliminated in vanadium-strengthened HSLA steels containing as much as 0.020% nitrogen.

Chart 1

This is good news for steelmakers using electric-arc furnaces since this process can yield over twice as much nitrogen as the basic-oxygen furnace. With an ever-increasing percentage of steel being made in the electric-arc furnace, the average nitrogen level of steel products is constantly rising. Using vanadium to strengthen high-strength, low-alloy steels converts nitrogen from an undesirable impurity into an effective alloy.

Steelmakers melting in basic-oxygen furnaces can also safely obtain additional strengthening from their vanadium additions by raising the nitrogen level of steel. In the presence of vanadium, this higher nitrogen does not create a strain-aging problem.

Optimum Strengthening

Slow cooling after austenite is transformed into ferrite will optimize strengthening from vanadium and nitrogen. This practice maximizes the precipitation of the vanadium nitrides that provide strengthening while eliminating strain aging. For strip steels, coiling temperatures of 600 to 630 deg. C (1,100 to 1,150 deg. F.) followed by slow cooling in the coil optimizes vanadium-nitride precipitation.

Data Sheet on Strain Aging (.PDF)